RESEARCH
|
Screening
& Diagnosis
BLOOD LEAD SCREENING IN CHINA: ORGANIZATION, QUALITY
ASSURANCE AND RESULTS
Dr.
Xingquan Zheng
Introduction
Lead and its compounds
exist universally. Because of their adverse health effects, especially
on children, they have been some of the most important pollutants impacting
human beings. Since 1981, The Institute of Environmental Health Monitoring,
Chinese academy for preventive medicine, as an institute under the Ministry
of Public Health, has focused attention on monitoring lead pollution,
its prevention and in adopting countermeasures against the hazardous
effect of lead. Blood
lead level is still the best and most sensitive biomarker for identifying
lead pollution, human exposure and its adverse effects. As early as
in 1972, there were reports referring blood lead levels in the general
population in China, but quality assurance procedures were not taken,
and hence, the reliability of results was not assured. To determine
the status of lead pollution in living environment and human exposure
in China, a nationwide blood lead screening program has been conducted
since 1983. In this program, a strictly quality assurance procedure
was taken as that in WHO/UNEP's global biological monitoring program
to ensure that the results would be accurate and comparable. The following
are what we did in a screening project and the results that were obtained
from the study. Organization
and Quality Control in Blood Lead Screening Project
1. Studies on
the preparations of quality control samples for blood lead analysis
The analytical
results of blood lead usually are over-reported due to contamination
of equipment in sampling and analysis. To ensure the accuracy of results,
we prepared a set of quality control (QC) samples with bovine blood
that consist of 23 lead levels. three of them have been approved by
State Bureau of Technical Supervision as certified reference material
(GBW 09132~GBW 09134), which can be used publicly as interior quality
control (IQC) samples (Table 1). The other 20 are used as external (blind)
quality control (EQC) samples. Table
1 Certified lead and cadmium values of bovine blood
|
Code
|
unit
|
Pb
certified
value ±
SD
|
Cd
certified
value±SD
|
|
GBW 09132
|
m g/l
|
112 ±
15
|
1.05 ±
0.17
|
|
GBW 09133
|
m g/l
|
284 ±
18
|
4.22 ±
0.33
|
|
GBW 09134
|
m g/l
|
386 ±
20
|
8.84 ±
0.49
|
2.
compile a detailed protocol for blood lead monitoring project.
To standardize the
methods and procedures in sampling of target populations, collecting
blood samples, the quality control in analytical phase and data treatment,
a detailed protocol was designed.
3.
training
A
training course was conducted for responsible staffs from each city
or investigation site involved. The content of this course included:
a.
purpose and significance of this project.
b.
method of sampling target population.
c.
method of collecting blood sample.
d methods
for avoidance of contamination during blood sampling and analysis and
their
importance.
e.
the procedure and the requirements of quality control in analytical
phase. f.
the method of determination of blood lead.
g.
data treatment and report
4. questionnaire
A
standard questionnaire was filled in by the participants or interviewer
and used as a basic questionnaire for each city and investigated site
selected, but it might be slightly modified, if necessary, with permission
by the central organizer.
5. Quality
control in analytical phase
Quality
control of analytical results was accomplished through analyzing the
EQC (unknown to analysts) together with test samples. When the project
started, 3~5 sets of quality control blood samples were analyzed. Each
set of QC sample consisted of 6 EQC and 2 IQC blood samples with different
lead levels. By communicating the evaluation report of the analytical
results and by giving technical instructions, the accuracy of the analytical
results was improved. During the analysis of the true samples, each
batch (50~70) of test sample together with one set of quality control
blood were analyzed in the following sequence (Fig.1). The results of
QC blood analyzed were sent to us for evaluation.
|
Calibration
curve |
|
IQC
|
|
EQC
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
10 Test samples |
|
IQC
|
|
10 Test samples
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
IQC or calibration
curve
|
|
|
|
Fig. 1 the
analytical sequence Since
the EQC were analyzed as unknown samples together with the test samples,
the accuracy of results from the EQC reflected the accuracy of those
from test samples. If the results from EQC samples could not meet the
criteria for acceptance, the entire process of analysis had to be repeated.
Blood
Lead Levels (PbB) of General Populations in China
Fig
1 shows the PbB levels of non-smoking women in various regions of China
during 1986~1988. Here we only presents the results from non-smoking
women because they best reflect the status of lead pollution in the
living environment, without the influence of smoking and their lead
burden being transferred to new born infants directly. According to
this survey, the blood lead level in the city ranged from 28~112m
g/dL, while the total geometric mean of investigated women is 60.6m
g/dL. About 8.4% of investigated women had PbB levels over 100m
g/L. Fig.2 shows the range of blood lead burden in one city.

|
Fig.1 PbB
of nonsmoker women, 1986~88
|
Fig.2 change
of PbB level in 1983~1998
(nonsmoker
women)
|
It
reveals that the average PbB levels was tending to increase with time
and there was a sharper increase in the period of 1995~1998 probably
due to a rapid increase in the number of vehicles. Table 2 and 3 indicate
the range of PbB of preschool children living in urban areas and in
small towns, respectively. The percentage of children with PbB levels
higher than 100m g/dl were also listed. It indicates that the problem
of lead exposure in children is severe, especially the children in small
towns where there are many small factories.
Table 2: PbB of children living in urban area (mcg/dl)
| |
6~24 month
|
>24~48
month
|
>48~72
month
|
|
No. of cities/sites
|
5
|
5
|
8
|
|
Geometric
mean, Range of cities
|
40~93
|
66~102
|
74~83
|
|
PbB>100m
g/l (%), Range of cities
|
22~45
|
33~53
|
16~44
|
Table
3: PbB of children living in small town (mcg/dl)
| |
6~24 month
|
>24~48
month
|
>48~72
month
|
|
No. of cities/sites
|
3
|
3
|
4
|
|
Geometric
mean, Range of cities
|
88~202
|
44~166
|
122~264
|
|
PbB>100m
g/l (%), Range of cities
|
43~87
|
24~77
|
17~90
|
Table
4 shows the range of PbB with age in a group of infants from 0 month
(unbilical blood) to 24 months old in Beijing. It indicates that their
PbB was increasing steadily with growth, and with the highest PbB at
24 months old. This might be due to infants consuming more food and
becoming more active with age. foods usually have higher lead content
than milk does, and 24-month old infants may have more chance to contact
with dust, which contains very high concentration of lead.
Table 4: Range of PbB vs. age (mcg/dl)
| |
0 month
|
6 mo.
|
12 mo.
|
18 mo.
|
24 mo.
|
|
No. of case
|
141
|
212
|
196
|
182
|
156
|
|
Geo. mean,
m g/l
|
48.5
|
56.4
|
68.4
|
80.4
|
87.2
|
|
Geo. SD
|
1.65
|
1.64
|
1.60
|
1.48
|
1.46
|
|
>100m
g/l, %
|
7.1
|
10.8
|
18.4
|
24.2
|
32.0
|
PbB
screening is only the first step in prevention of the hazardous effects
of lead pollution. Numerous unsolved problems are still facing us before
we can successfully protect children from lead pollution. Coordination
including information exchange is urgently needed between scientists
from different countries.
References
1.
Zheng Xingquan et. al.: The status and trends of pollutants in human
beings in China, No. 2, Lead and Cadmium, Report to Ministry of Public
Health, 1990, Institute of Environmental Health Monitoring, Chinese
Academy for Preventive Medicine.
2.
Zheng Xingquan et.al.: The blood lead levels of preschool children
in Beijing and its relationship to their mother or nurses, J. of Hygiene
Research, 22(supplement 4):29,1993
3.
Liu Jianrong, Zheng XQ et.al.: Dynamic study on blood lead levels
of pregnant women and infants in a district of Beijing, J. of Hygiene
Research, 26(1):38,1997.
4.
Zheng Xingquan et.al.: Lead exposure and its effects on preschool
children in Beijing, In: Human exposure to lead, WHO/EHG/95.15.
|